Cast of 'Music Man' Hits All the Right Notes by Mark Lowry
Jeff McCarthy -- taking a break from Broadway's Urinetown to perform here -- gives us a slightly different Hill than we've seen before. He's slick, all right, but not so wrapped up in his own devices that the human inside is completely invisible. He's also a little sexier than Hill usually is, but in an unknowing way, which makes him all the more potent.